Homemade Tomato Sauce – Is it worth it?

Along with informative links, some posts contain affiliate links, thank you for supporting this blog and our family by purchasing through my links!

Homemade Tomato Sauce – Is it worth it?


I can’t say I actually “like” homesteading, although I believe it is the way to go with the world as it is today. I tend to be on the slightly lazy side and lets be honest, homesteading is hard work! I try my best and my hubby loves it when I am in the kitchen canning and blanching, juicing and chopping, slicing and dicing. But if I were to just be blatantly honest… my modern woman laziness influences my mindset fairly often.

For example, I canned my own straight-from-the-garden homemade tomato sauce! But I can’t help but to think, “I could have grabbed a can off the shelf at the grocery store in all of 5 seconds!”


So let’s think about all the work that goes into making these beautiful red luscious juicy tomatoes into a jar of sauce.

First, of course, you have to grow them which means you have to till the soil, plant the seeds (or plants), tie them up, pull the weeds around them, add fertilizer,  keep the tomato horn worms off (usually by hand plucking them off and tossing them to the nearby chickens.) All this “fun” stuff, my hubby does. It is after all of that when I have to do something with them. All his hard work (which ironically he LOVES to do) makes me feel pretty obligated to do “my part” of the job when harvest time comes. Seriously, what kind of wifey would I be if I just sat there and let all of his hard work go to rot because I refused to preserve the food?

SO, what exactly does “my part” include?

Rinsing Tomatoes

After picking the tomatoes (which is our kid’s job), I have to wash them and “de-stem” them, which is not so bad, I just rub the stem of the little ones and the green stuff pops right off. The bigger ones have to be twisted off, but still not to bad.

Cutting Tomatoes

Then I have to cut them up into my “big ol’ pot” to cook. This is messy and takes some time. I tried to save time cutting multiple small tomatoes at a time. That helped a little but I had to be careful not to cut my hand, thankfully I used my ceramic knife which isn’t as mean as my stainless steal ones.  The big tomatoes were real fun, they would send a cascade of tomato juice running down my arm all the way to my elbow each time I cut them (I’m short).

Electric Hand Blender

The Ball Canning Book’s recipe (page 362) says, “Using a potato masher, crush tomatoes to release juices, stirring constantly.” Well, I think to my self, “Yeah, potato mashers are so “last millennium!” and grab my electric hand blender! I plunge that bad boy into the tomatoes and have juice in a matter of seconds… and it stirs it too! I lifted it in and out basically playing “whack a mole… err tomato” with the pieces as they swirl around. (Use caution here if you are using my method, the juice is beginning to get hot and going nuts with a hand blender in a pot of ‘maters may actually splash scalding juicy tomato parts onto you, so… yeah, be careful!)

Boiling Tomatoes

In no time we have frothy boiling tomato juice! The book says to cook for 10 minutes to get the juice out, at this point it’s probably not really  necessary because it has been blended and about to go in my strainer but I let it boil a while. I guess I was just having a moment of obedience.

Juicing Tomatoes

Next, I let it cool a little and then start running it through my Roma Food Strainer. Juice comes out one end and … goo, consisting of seeds & skins and pulp, comes out the other. Warning: Plunging the red plunger down hastily because you are impatient, causes the juice to come out of the strainer screen part in super soaker style aimed right at your face.. and it’s still hot!

Cooking Down Tomatoes

I get all that juice and pour it back in to my big ol’ pot and let it cook… it takes FOR-EV-ER to cook down to a sauce instead of juice consistency. I gave up before I got it to “store bought” thickness, so I have a “thin sauce.”

Tomatoe Sauce

Thank God for dish washers that can sterilized jars, which I had “done up” ahead of time. I don’t bother with sanitizing the rings because they aren’t touching the food so as long as they are clean I don’t care to take the time to boil or preheat them, it just seemed pointless to me. I drop my lids into a small sauce pan and have them boiling, so that the rubber gasket is softened and ready to put them on the jars after I fill ‘em up! I add the salt and lemon juice for acidification and flavor. Pour in my sauce to the proper headspace, wipe the rims, plop the lid on, and screw down the ring. Then into water bath canner to cook for another 35 minutes (for pints.)

Canned Tomatoe Sauce

And when it was all said and done, I had 9 pints of thin tomato sauce. Which probably would cost about $25 for organic tomato sauce at a store. I would say it isn’t worth it, the time, the mess, the burns … all for 9 pints of tomato sauce. It would have been much easier to just grab a can from the store and move on with my day… But after the job is done and I look at my little jars all lined up on my counter there is a great sense of pride knowing the hard work went into those jars. I know where it came from, what is in them, how it was processed, when it was canned, and that it was done with tons of love and hard work! I know it is truly organic, non-GMO, Kosher, and farm raised! And the TASTE of homegrown homemade sauce is better than anything you can buy from a store!!  So, yeah, even for a fairly lazy domestically challenged person that I am, I say it’s worth it!

“Nothing in the world is worth having or worth doing unless it means effort, pain, difficulty… I have never in my life envied a human being who led an easy life. I have envied a great many people who led difficult lives and led them well.” ~Theodore Roosevelt


Check out the great products I talked about in my blog on my “Homesteading” section of my aStore at Amazon.com!!!



Blessings to you,


© Becky Husband & Oh Happy Daze Disclaimers

Affiliate Links: Thank you for supporting my blog by purchasing through these links.

Christianbook.com carries a wide variety of Christian, Hebrew Roots, & Messianic products along with an abundant amount of homeschool curriculum, inspirational books, movies, music, gifts and more!!


Find pretty much anything you need at Amazon.com


Ads that are displayed below this point are NOT my ads but those of WordPress.com and are not necessarily approved or supported by Becky Husband or Oh Happy Daze. If you saw an inappropriate ad, please report it!

About Becky Husband

Becky is a Hebraic Christian homeschool mom blogger that lives on a small farm in Deep East Texas. When she isn't homeschooling her kids, she is busy documenting her family's life on her blog. In her blog, she writes about her faith, family, homeschooling, and homesteading. She also shares the family's abundance of hobbies such as geocaching, hiking, biking, birding, nature photography, and most recently her art! She is always eager to answer any questions others may have so feel free to leave comments and inquiries!

Posted on July 24, 2014, in Homesteading, In The Kitchen and tagged . Bookmark the permalink. Leave a comment.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: